Introduction

Analyze the Cartoon

C.J. Taylor. "The Mortar of Assimilation - and the One Element that Won't Mix", 1889. From Puck magazine. Open larger version of cartoon in a new tab.

Key points from the cartoon:

  • The spoon labeled "Equal Rights" suggests the immigrants will be treated equal to other citizens
  • The character looks like "Lady Liberty," who symbolizes America.
  • Notice that the people look and are dressed differently, suggesting they are from various cultures and backgrounds.
  • Notice the man who looks angry or hostile. Do you think he is angry at the other immigrants or "Lady Liberty"? Why?
  • The "melting pot" being stirred by "Lady Liberty" is labeled citizenship. What does this suggest?

 

 

Next Page